
Lease vs Buy a Car in Canada: What a $40,000 Car Really Costs
A lease payment is almost always lower than a loan payment on the same car. Whether leasing is actually cheaper depends on tax, kilometres and what happens at the end.
- Figures checked November 18, 2026
- By Krish Paul
- 8 min read
On this page
We priced the same $40,000 car both ways in Ontario, then added the charges that can turn a cheap lease into an expensive one.
The short answer
Over a short period, leasing can cost less than buying. In our hypothetical Ontario example, leasing a $40,000 car for 48 months cost $1,348.14 less than buying it with a loan and selling it after four years. That edge disappears if you drive about 11,200 kilometres more than the allowance at $0.12 per kilometre, pay for wear and tear, end the lease early or buy the car out.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) sums up the trade-off: lease payments are generally lower than loan payments with the same term, but you may pay more overall, you do not own the car, and breaking a lease early may be very costly. The numbers below show where that line falls.
Lease vs buy: a $40,000 car over four years
Here is one car, two ways to pay for it. The price is $40,000 before tax, the interest rate is 5.99% on both the lease and the loan, and you live in Ontario.
| Hypothetical $40,000 car, 5.99% | Lease, 48 months | Buy, 60-month loan |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly payment, HST included | $598.70 | $873.63 |
| Paid over the first four years | $28,737.44 | $41,934.36 |
| Loan still owing after four years | $0 | $10,151.22 |
| Car value you keep after four years | $0 | $22,000 (assumed) |
| Net cost of four years of driving | $28,737.44 | $30,085.58 |
Hypothetical example. Lease: 48 monthly payments made at the start of each month, $0 down, a $22,000 (55%) residual and 13% HST on each payment. Loan: 60 months on $45,200 ($40,000 plus 13% HST), with the car assumed to be worth its $22,000 residual at month 48.
The lease payment covers the $18,000 the car is expected to lose in value plus interest on the money tied up in it. The loan payment repays the whole price, so it is higher, but at month 48 you own a car worth about $22,000 and still owe $10,151.22. Sell it, pay off the loan and your net cost of four years of driving is $30,085.58.
The lease comes out $1,348.14 ahead in this example. Part of the gap is tax: the lease charges HST only on the payments, while the buyer pays HST on the full price and, here, borrows it at 5.99%. Using the same rate on both sides is a simplification. A real offer may carry different rates for leasing and financing, which can swing the result either way.
Why the lease looks cheaper: tax is charged as you go
The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) says that when you lease a vehicle from a GST/HST registrant, you pay GST/HST on your lease payments. For a lease longer than three months, the rate is the one for the province where the vehicle must be registered. In Ontario that is 13%, according to the CRA rate table.
When you buy, you pay HST on the full price on day one. In our example that is $5,200. When you lease and hand the car back, you pay tax only on your 48 payments, which comes to $3,306.08. The catch is the buyout. Buying the car at the end of the lease is a purchase, and the CRA says GST/HST generally applies when you buy a vehicle from a registrant. Add 13% on the $22,000 buyout and the total HST reaches $6,166.08.
So the tax advantage of leasing only exists if you return the car. If you plan to keep it, leasing first and buying later means paying HST on the lease interest as well as on the car. In our example, leasing and then buying out costs $53,597.44 in total, while buying and paying off the loan costs $52,085.58. That is $1,511.86 more for the same car.
Outside Ontario the gap changes. Alberta, for example, has only the 5% GST, so the tax effect is smaller. Provinces with a separate provincial sales tax have their own rules for leases.
The costs that flip the result
Kilometres over the allowance
Every lease sets a kilometre limit. Toyota Canada offers allowances of 16,000, 20,000 and 24,000 km a year. Go over, and you pay a charge for each extra kilometre. A November 2026 Honda lease offer for Ontario, published through an Ontario Honda dealer, lists $0.12 per kilometre over a 100,000 km allowance on a 60-month lease.
In our example, the lease saves $1,348.14. At $0.12 a kilometre, about 11,200 extra kilometres wipes that out. If you choose a 16,000 km a year allowance but actually drive 20,000 km a year, you finish four years 16,000 km over and owe $1,920. The lease then costs $571.86 more than buying.
What will extra kilometres cost you?
Enter the total kilometres you expect to drive over the whole lease, the total allowance in the contract and the charge per extra kilometre. The result updates as you type.
The charge is the kilometres over the allowance multiplied by the per-kilometre rate in your contract. Tax may apply on top, and some leases let you buy extra kilometres up front at a lower rate. Calculator by Gizly.
If you are not sure how much you drive, check your odometer against your last oil change or service records before you choose the allowance. Toyota says that on its 24,000 km plan you can buy extra kilometres up front at a reduced rate, while buying them at lease end costs the standard rate.
Wear and tear
The FCAC notes you may have to pay extra fees for excessive wear and tear when you return a leased car. Dents, stained seats and worn tires can all show up on the final bill. Toyota sells an optional waiver called Wear Pass that covers items such as dents, stains, extra kilometres and tire wear at lease end, though it is not available in British Columbia. A waiver has its own price, so add it to the lease cost when you compare.
Ending the lease early
Life changes. A move, a new baby or a job loss can make a lease the wrong fit halfway through. The FCAC warns that breaking a lease early may be very costly. A loan is more flexible: Honda Canada says its retail loans can be paid out early without prepayment penalties, and if you sell a financed car you keep any value above what you owe.
The money you put down
Our example uses $0 down on both sides. A down payment on a lease lowers the monthly payment but does not buy you any ownership. It is simply part of what you pay to use the car, so count it in the lease total when you compare.
When leasing makes sense
Leasing tends to work for a narrow group of drivers. Check yourself against all four.
- You drive less than the allowanceYou know it from records, not a guess.
- You want a new car every few yearsThe FCAC lists this as one of the advantages of leasing.
- You will return the carIn our example, buying out the lease cost more than buying the car from the start.
- Your plans are stable for the whole termAn early exit can erase any savings.
How to compare a real lease and loan offer
- Get both offers on the same car. Ask for the selling price, interest rate, term, fees and total cost for a lease and a loan, in writing.
- Read the disclosure statement. The FCAC says provincial consumer protection laws apply to car leases and most provinces require the dealer to give you a disclosure statement showing the total cost and your obligations.
- Find the residual value. This is the buyout price at lease end. Toyota calls it the Lease End Value. A higher residual means lower payments but a bigger buyout.
- Check the kilometre allowance and the rate per extra kilometre. Use the calculator above with your real driving.
- Price your exit. Ask what it would cost to end the lease after one and two years.
- Compare net cost, not monthly payment. For the loan, subtract what the car will be worth when you would sell it. For the lease, add likely kilometre and wear charges.
Running a car costs more than the payment. If you drive in the GTA, see whether a 407 transponder is worth it, and check the winter tire insurance discount in Ontario before your next renewal.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to lease or buy a car in Canada?
It depends on how long you keep the car, and the FCAC warns that leasing may cost more overall. Over a short period, a lease can cost less if you stay within the kilometre allowance and return the car in good shape. In our hypothetical Ontario example, a 48-month lease cost $1,348.14 less than buying and selling after four years, but only before any excess kilometre or wear charges.
How much does it cost to go over the kilometres on a lease?
It depends on your contract. You multiply the kilometres over the allowance by the per-kilometre rate. One Honda lease offer for Ontario in November 2026 lists $0.12 per extra kilometre, so 16,000 extra kilometres would cost $1,920 at that rate.
Do you pay HST on a car lease in Ontario?
Yes. The CRA says that when you lease a vehicle from a GST/HST registrant, you pay GST/HST on your lease payments. For leases longer than three months, the rate is the one for the province where the vehicle must be registered, which is 13% in Ontario.
Can you end a car lease early?
It depends on your contract, and it can be expensive. The FCAC says breaking a lease early may be very costly. Read the early termination section of your lease and its disclosure statement before you sign, and ask the dealer for the exact cost in writing.
Should I buy out my lease at the end?
Compare the buyout price in your contract with what similar cars sell for. If the car is worth more than the buyout price, buying it can make sense. Remember that the purchase is generally taxable, so in Ontario you pay 13% HST on the buyout price on top of the HST already paid on the lease payments.
- Sources, checked November 18, 2026: FCAC: Car financing options (modified 2025-10-14); FCAC: How you are protected when buying a car (modified 2025-10-14); CRA: GST/HST and motor vehicles (modified 2024-08-29); CRA: GST/HST rates by province; Toyota Canada: Lease vs finance; Honda Canada: Lease options; Honda Financial Services lease offer for the 2026 Pilot Sport, Ontario, valid November 3 to 30, 2026, as published by an Ontario Honda dealer.
- Method: Lease payments use the standard annuity formula with payments in advance and a $22,000 residual, checked by simulating the lease balance month by month down to exactly $22,000. The loan balance at month 48 was computed by month-by-month amortization and confirmed with the closed-form balance formula. All figures are hypothetical, exclude fees, licence, insurance and the return you could earn on money not spent, and assume the car is worth its residual value at month 48.
Important: This guide is general information, not financial or legal advice. Lease and loan terms, rates and fees vary by dealer, lender and province, and the rates in our example are hypothetical. Read your contract and disclosure statement before you sign. Gizly is not paid by any company mentioned here. See our affiliate disclosure.
Send it to a friend, a family member or a coworker with the same question. It takes one tap.
How this page was made: Gizly uses AI tools to help research and draft its guides. Krish Paul, the editor, is responsible for what Gizly publishes. Spot an error? Tell us and we will fix it.
Keep reading
Compare before you switch
Rates and offers checked against each bank’s own page.


