Checked at the source. Every page dated.

Low Interest vs Cash Back Credit Card in Canada: The Break-Even Balance

Low Interest vs Cash Back Credit Card in Canada: The Break-Even Balance

Cash back looks free until you carry a balance. Once interest kicks in, a card with no rewards and a lower rate can leave you with more money at the end of the year.

  • Rates checked November 19, 2026
  • By Krish Paul
  • 8 min read
On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. The four cards in this comparison
  3. Worked example: a household spending $24,000 a year
  4. Hidden costs that move the break-even line
  5. You do not have to pick only one card
  6. How to decide in five steps
  7. Frequently asked questions

This guide compares real Canadian cards from the same bank, works out the balance where each one wins, and lists the costs that move that line.

The short answer

If you regularly carry a balance of more than a few thousand dollars, a low-interest card usually costs less than a cash back card, even after you count the rewards. In our hypothetical example, a household spending $24,000 a year comes out ahead with the TD Low Rate Visa once its average balance passes about $3,500, and with a no-fee low-rate card once it passes about $1,800.

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) makes the same point in its guide to choosing a credit card: the interest rate may be an important factor if you regularly carry a balance, and it matters less if you pay in full every month. The break-even balance depends on your own spending, so use the calculator below.

Which TD card costs you less?

Enter the balance you usually carry and what you spend in a year. The result updates as you type.

TD Low Rate Visa saves you$137 a yearCash back of $432 minus the $114 higher annual fee leaves $318. Each $1,000 of average balance costs $90.90 more a year at 21.99% than at 12.90%, so the two cards break even at an average balance of $3,498.

Compares the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card (21.99%, $139 fee, 3% and 1% cash back) with the TD Low Rate Visa Card (12.90%, $25 fee, no cash back) at rates on TD’s pages checked November 19, 2026. Assumes no 3% category goes over its $15,000 yearly cap, no welcome offers and no missed payments. Calculator by Gizly.

Two separate key rings hanging on brass hooks beside a front door in winter
Two cards, two jobs: one for the balance you carry, one for spending you clear each month. Image: AI-generated for Gizly.

The four cards in this comparison

To keep the comparison fair, we paired cards that differ mainly in rate and rewards. Two come from TD, which sells both a low-rate card and a cash back card, and the other two are no-fee versions of the same trade-off.

Four Canadian credit cards compared: annual fee, purchase rate, cash advance rate and cash back
Card Annual fee Purchase rate Cash advance rate Cash back
TD Low Rate Visa $25 12.90% 12.90% None
MBNA True Line Mastercard $0 12.99% 24.99% None
TD Cash Back Visa $0 21.99% 22.99% 1% on 5 categories, 0.5% on the rest
TD Cash Back Visa Infinite $139 21.99% 22.99% 3% on 5 categories, 1% on the rest

Sources: each card’s product page, checked November 19, 2026. The five TD categories are grocery, gas and EV charging, public transit, recurring bills, and streaming, gaming and digital media. Higher rates apply after missed payments.

The TD Cash Back Visa Infinite also requires $60,000 in personal income or $100,000 in household income. TD’s Low Rate Visa page lists no income requirement. Neither low-rate card earns cash back.

Worked example: a household spending $24,000 a year

Take a hypothetical household that puts $2,000 a month on one card. Of the $24,000 a year, $6,000 is groceries, $2,400 is gas and $1,200 is recurring bills, for $9,600 in categories that earn 3% on the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite. No single category goes over the $15,000 yearly cap. The other $14,400 earns 1%.

  • Cash back earned: $9,600 at 3% is $288, plus $14,400 at 1% is $144, for $432 a year.
  • Extra annual fee: $139 for the Cash Back Visa Infinite minus $25 for the Low Rate Visa is $114.
  • Head start for the rewards card: $432 minus $114 is $318 a year, before any interest.
  • Extra interest: 21.99% minus 12.90% is 9.09 percentage points, or $90.90 a year for each $1,000 of average balance.
  • Break-even: $318 divided by 0.0909 is $3,498.
Yearly result of two TD cards by average balance carriedFor a household spending $24,000 a year, the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card leaves you $293 ahead at a $0 balance and $1,026 behind at a $6,000 average balance. The TD Low Rate Visa Card leaves you $25 behind at $0 and $799 behind at $6,000. The lines cross at an average balance of about $3,500.$0$500 behind$1,000 behind$0$2,000$4,000$6,000Average balance carried$293 ahead$25 behindLow Rate$799 behindCash Back VI$1,026 behind
Yearly result (cash back minus annual fee minus interest) for the hypothetical $24,000-a-year household, by average balance carried. Rates and fees from TD’s product pages, checked November 19, 2026. Chart by Gizly.

With no balance, the Cash Back Visa Infinite leaves this household $293 ahead for the year, while the Low Rate Visa leaves it $25 behind because of its fee. At a $6,000 average balance the picture flips: the cash back card ends $1,026 behind and the low-rate card $799 behind. At $5,000, the low-rate card saves about $137 a year, and at $10,000 it saves $591.

No-fee cards break even sooner

Many people compare two no-fee cards instead. Here the rewards side is thinner. The TD Cash Back Visa pays 1% in the same five categories, capped at the first $5,000 a year in each, and 0.5% on everything else. For the same household that works out to $163 a year: $55 on groceries, $24 on gas, $12 on bills and $72 on other spending.

Break-even balance for two no-fee cardsStep 1: the no-fee TD Cash Back Visa earns $163 a year in the example. Step 2: its purchase rate is 21.99%, 9.00 points above the 12.99% MBNA True Line Mastercard. Step 3: $163 divided by 0.09 gives a break-even average balance of $1,811.$163Cash back a year on the no-fee TD Cash Back Visa9.00 pointsRate gap: 21.99% versus 12.99% at MBNA True Line$1,811Break-even balance: $163 divided by 0.09
How the break-even balance works for two no-fee cards, using the same hypothetical spending. Rates from TD and MBNA product pages, checked November 19, 2026. Infographic by Gizly.

Against the MBNA True Line Mastercard at 12.99%, the rate gap is 9.00 points. Divide $163 by 0.09 and the break-even average balance is $1,811. Carry more than that and the no-fee low-rate card wins.

Hidden costs that move the break-even line

Carrying a balance also costs you on new purchases

Federally regulated card issuers must give you a grace period of at least 21 days, but only when you pay in full. The FCAC says you pay interest if you do not pay your balance in full by the due date, and you keep paying it until the balance is paid back in full. That means new purchases add to the balance you pay interest on, so your real average balance is often higher than the amount you think you are carrying.

Missed payments erase the low rate

The TD Low Rate Visa page says a standard rate of 24.99% on purchases and 27.99% on cash advances applies if the minimum payment is not received. Once that happens, most of the rate advantage is gone. Our guide to missing a credit card payment explains how penalty rates work and how long they last.

Cash advance rates differ more than purchase rates

TD charges 12.90% on cash advances on its Low Rate Visa, the same as purchases. MBNA charges 24.99% on True Line cash advances, nearly double its purchase rate. If you sometimes take cash from your card, check this line before choosing. TD’s page also notes that fees apply to each cash advance.

Welcome offers and promotions end

Both TD cards currently offer a first-year annual fee rebate if you meet the conditions, and the Low Rate Visa offers 0% on purchases for the first 6 months. MBNA advertises a 0% promotional rate on balance transfers for 12 months, after which its standard balance transfer rate is 17.99%. These help in year one, but the break-even math above is what applies every year after.

You do not have to pick only one card

If you have an old balance and also spend on a card each month, splitting the job can beat either card alone.

  • Keep the balance on the low-rate cardPay it down there and stop adding to it.
  • Use the rewards card only for spending you pay in fullPaid in full by the due date, it keeps its grace period and its cash back.
  • Watch two due datesSet automatic minimum payments on both so a slip does not trigger a penalty rate.

How to decide in five steps

  1. Find your real average balance. Look at your last six statements and note the balance you carried after each payment.
  2. Add up your yearly spending by category. Your statements or banking app will show grocery, gas and bill totals.
  3. Work out the cash back you would really earn. Apply each card’s rates and caps, then subtract any annual fee.
  4. Divide by the rate gap. Net cash back divided by the difference in purchase rates gives your break-even balance.
  5. Compare and plan the payoff. If your balance is above the break-even, the low-rate card wins. Either way, a plan to clear the balance saves more than any card choice. Our debt avalanche vs snowball guide shows how.

Remember that paying only the minimum keeps the balance high for years. Our minimum payment guide shows how long that takes. If you pay in full every month, the rate barely matters, and a cash back card is usually the better pick.

Frequently asked questions

Is a low interest credit card better if I carry a balance?

Usually, once the balance is large enough. In our hypothetical example of $24,000 a year in spending, the TD Low Rate Visa costs less than the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite once the average balance passes $3,498, because each $1,000 carried costs $90.90 more a year at 21.99% than at 12.90%.

How do I work out my break-even balance?

Take the cash back the rewards card would pay you in a year, subtract any extra annual fee, and divide by the gap between the two purchase rates. For example, $318 divided by 0.0909 is $3,498. If your average balance is higher than the result, the low-rate card costs less.

Do I lose the interest-free period if I carry a balance?

Yes. Federally regulated issuers must give a grace period of at least 21 days, but the FCAC says you pay interest if you do not pay your balance in full by the due date, and you keep paying it until the balance is paid back in full. New purchases then add to the balance that collects interest.

Can I keep my rewards card and get a low-rate card too?

Yes. Many people keep an old balance on a low-rate card while paying it down and use a rewards card only for spending they pay in full each month. That way the rewards card keeps its grace period and its cash back.

What happens to a low-rate card if I miss payments?

The rate can jump. The TD Low Rate Visa page says a standard rate of 24.99% on purchases and 27.99% on cash advances applies if the minimum payment is not received, which wipes out most of the advantage over a rewards card.

  • Sources, checked November 19, 2026: FCAC: Choosing a credit card (modified 2025-10-15); FCAC: How credit cards work (modified 2025-10-15); TD Low Rate Visa Card (rates stated as current as of June 1, 2026); TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card (rates stated as current as of April 30, 2025); TD Cash Back Visa Card (rates stated as current as of September 1, 2026); MBNA True Line Mastercard (no as-of date shown).
  • Method: Yearly result is cash back minus annual fee minus interest, with interest taken as the annual purchase rate times the average balance. This assumes you pay the interest each month so the balance stays level. All figures were computed in Python and checked twice: a day-by-day interest count gave the same results to the cent, and an amortization of the FCAC’s own $4,000 example reproduced its totals within $3. Spending figures are hypothetical. Welcome offers, missed payments and category caps beyond those noted are excluded.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

Send it to a friend, a family member or a coworker with the same question. It takes one tap.

How this page was made: Gizly uses AI tools to help research and draft its guides. Krish Paul, the editor, is responsible for what Gizly publishes. Spot an error? Tell us and we will fix it.

Keep reading

Compare before you switch

Rates and offers checked against each bank’s own page.

Krish Paul

Krish Paul owns and edits Gizly, an independent Canadian money site. Each guide cites the government rules and institution terms it relies on, with the date the figures were checked.

Gizly
Logo