Checked at the source. Every page dated.

Is a Debt Consolidation Loan Worth It in Canada? The Real Cost

Is a Debt Consolidation Loan Worth It in Canada? The Real Cost

A consolidation loan swaps several high-rate balances for one lower payment. Whether it saves you money depends less on the rate than on the term and the fees.

  • Rules checked November 21, 2026
  • By Krish Paul
  • 7 min read
On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What $15,000 of card debt costs under five plans
  3. Why a lower payment can cost more
  4. Where consolidation loans come from
  5. The habit test
  6. How to check a consolidation offer
  7. Frequently asked questions

We ran the numbers on a $15,000 credit card balance to show when a loan wins, when it quietly costs more, and how to check an offer yourself.

The short answer

A debt consolidation loan saves money only when its rate, with every fee counted, is lower than your current rate and you pay it off about as fast as you would have paid the debts. A lower monthly payment over a longer term can cost more in total, even at a lower rate.

That is the warning in the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) guide to debt consolidation: a lower rate may save money, but a longer repayment period can add interest, and you may only qualify for a rate that is higher than what you pay now.

Does a consolidation loan beat your card?

Enter your balance and the loan you were offered. The card side assumes a 21.99% rate and the same monthly payment as the loan.

Interest on the loan$2,422
Interest staying on the card$7,369

A 36-month loan at 9.99% costs $483.94 a month and $2,422 in interest. Paying the same amount on a 21.99% card takes 47 months and $7,369 in interest, so the loan saves $4,947.

Interest is compounded monthly at the annual rate divided by 12. Fees you pay up front are not included unless you add them to the rate. Results are estimates. Calculator by Gizly.

Three mountain streams joining into one wide river in an autumn Canadian forest
Consolidation merges several debts into one payment, much as these streams join a single river. Image: AI-generated for Gizly.

What $15,000 of card debt costs under five plans

Here is a hypothetical example. You owe $15,000 on a card charging 21.99%, the purchase rate on the no-fee TD Cash Back Visa as of September 1, 2026. A lender offers you a consolidation loan. The loan rates below are made up for illustration, and interest is compounded monthly.

  • Card only. Paying $483.94 a month clears the card in 47 months with $7,369 of interest.
  • 36-month loan at 9.99%. The payment is the same $483.94, the debt is gone in 36 months, and interest totals $2,422. You save $4,947.
  • The same loan with a $750 fee added to the balance. The payment rises to $508.13, and interest plus the fee comes to $3,293.
  • 60-month loan at 9.99%. The payment drops to $318.63, but interest grows to $4,118. That is $1,696 more than the 36-month version.
  • 60-month loan at 19.99%. The payment is $397.32 and interest reaches $8,839, which is $1,471 more than staying on the card.
Interest on $15,000: credit card vs consolidation loansTotal interest and fees on a $15,000 balance: Card only, $484 a month: $7,369; 36-month loan, 9.99%: $2,422; 36-month loan, $750 fee: $3,293; 60-month loan, 9.99%: $4,118; 60-month loan, 19.99%: $8,839.Card only, $484 a month$7,36936-month loan, 9.99%$2,42236-month loan, $750 fee$3,29360-month loan, 9.99%$4,11860-month loan, 19.99%$8,839
Total interest and fees to clear a hypothetical $15,000 balance. The card is at 21.99%, the purchase rate on the no-fee TD Cash Back Visa as of September 1, 2026, paid at $483.94 a month. Loan rates are hypothetical. Chart by Gizly.

The last plan is the trap. It has a lower rate than the card and a payment that is about $87 a month lighter, so it feels like a win. But you pay for five years instead of just under four, and the extra time costs more than the rate saves.

Why a lower payment can cost more

It is easy to judge a loan by its monthly payment. A smaller payment does help cash flow, and that can matter if you are close to missing payments. But interest is charged on whatever you still owe each month, so every extra month of debt adds cost.

FCAC makes the same point with a simple loan example on its personal loans page: $2,000 at 19.99% costs about $2,220 in total over 12 months, $2,700 over 36 months and $3,180 over 60 months. Same rate, same amount, very different totals.

If you only make small payments, our guide to paying the credit card minimum shows how slowly a balance falls. The fair test is to compare the loan with what you would pay if you sent the same monthly amount to your current debts. That is what the calculator above does. If the loan only wins because you are paying it for longer, it is not saving you money.

Fees change the real rate

If a lender charges a set-up fee and adds it to the loan, you pay interest on the fee as well. In our example, a $750 fee on a 9.99% loan pushes the effective annual rate to about 13.4%. It still beats the card, but by much less.

Under section 347 of the Criminal Code, fees, fines, penalties and commissions count as interest when the 35% legal maximum is measured. Insurance charges and repayments of principal do not. FCAC also says the loan’s total cost is the amount borrowed plus interest plus any fees, so ask for that total in writing.

1. Is the loan’s rate, with every fee counted, lower than the rate on your debts?
Yes

Go to question 2.
No

Skip it. FCAC warns a higher rate would likely increase your debt.
2. Is the loan term no longer than it would take you to clear the debts now?
Yes

Go to question 3.
No

Check the total cost. A longer term can wipe out the rate saving.
3. Can you keep paying at least the loan payment every month?
Yes

Go to question 4.
No

Talk to a credit counsellor before you borrow more.
4. Will you stop using the cards the loan pays off?
Yes

A loan should save you money. Compare offers before you apply.
No

Wait. New card balances on top of the loan leave you deeper in debt.
Four checks before you sign. Based on the FCAC guidance on debt consolidation, checked November 21, 2026. Diagram by Gizly.

Where consolidation loans come from

FCAC lists several ways to consolidate, and each has its own trade-off.

  • Personal or debt consolidation loan from a bank or credit union. Regular payments and a set repayment period. This is the product the example above models.
  • Personal line of credit or home equity line of credit. Our HELOC limit guide covers how much you can borrow against a home. FCAC notes that payments typically cover only interest and the rate is usually variable, so you have to set your own payoff plan.
  • Balance transfer card. A low or 0% promotional rate, usually for about 6 to 18 months, with a transfer fee and a risk of losing the rate if you miss a payment.
  • Debt consolidation companies. These usually offer only loans, and regulation varies by province. FCAC suggests checking them with the Better Business Bureau and being cautious with any company that promises to fix your credit.

Credit counselling agencies and Licensed Insolvency Trustees do not sell consolidation loans, but FCAC lists them as professionals who offer other kinds of help if you are struggling.

The habit test

A loan clears the cards, but it does not change what filled them. FCAC advises you to stop using the paid-off cards and lines of credit and to avoid new credit.

  • Put the paid-off cards awayFCAC suggests that cutting up all but one card can help you stick to the plan.
  • Build a small cash bufferEven a few hundred dollars stops the next car repair from going on a card.
  • Track the total, not the paymentCheck the loan balance every month so you see it fall.

How to check a consolidation offer

  1. List every debt. Write down each balance, rate, monthly payment and annual fee. FCAC’s own example counts annual card fees as part of the cost.
  2. Work out your current payoff date. Use the calculator above or your card statement’s payoff estimate.
  3. Ask for the full cost in writing. Federally regulated lenders must tell you the rate, term, payment, fees and any optional services you accepted.
  4. Compare at the same payment. Run the loan at the payment you can afford now, not the lowest one offered.
  5. Check prepayment terms. Some lenders let you pay early without a penalty and some charge a fee. A loan you can pay off early protects you if your income rises.
  6. Decline extras you do not want. Creditor loan insurance is optional, and FCAC says you do not have to take it.

Frequently asked questions

Does a debt consolidation loan save money in Canada?

Only if its rate, with fees counted, is lower than the rate on your debts and you repay it on a similar timeline. In our hypothetical example, a 36-month loan at 9.99% saves $4,947 of interest on $15,000 of card debt at 21.99%. Stretching the same loan to 60 months gives back $1,696 of that saving.

Can a consolidation loan cost more than my credit cards?

Yes. FCAC warns that a longer repayment period may cost more interest over time. In our example, a 60-month loan at 19.99% costs $8,839 in interest, which is $1,471 more than paying the 21.99% card at $483.94 a month.

What is the highest interest rate a lender can charge in Canada?

The Criminal Code makes it an offence to lend at an annual percentage rate above 35%. Fees, penalties and commissions count as interest for that limit, while repayments of principal and insurance charges do not.

Will a debt consolidation loan hurt my credit score?

FCAC says applying to several lenders in a short time may lower your score, while paying the new loan on time and lowering high balances can help it. Compare offers first and apply only where you are likely to qualify.

Should I close my credit cards after consolidating?

FCAC advises you to stop using the cards and lines of credit the loan paid off and to avoid new credit. Whether to close a card afterwards is a separate decision.

Can I pay off a consolidation loan early?

FCAC says some lenders let you make extra payments or pay the loan off early with no penalty, while others charge a fee for paying early. Check the prepayment terms before you sign.

  • Sources, checked November 21, 2026: FCAC: Debt consolidation (modified 2025-10-14); FCAC Financial Toolkit: Consolidation loan; FCAC: Personal loans (modified 2025-10-14); Criminal Code, section 347, current to 2026-10-29; TD cash back credit cards (rates current as of September 1, 2026).
  • Method: Loan payments use the standard amortization formula with monthly compounding at the annual rate divided by 12. Card payoff was simulated month by month at the same payment. We checked the method by reproducing FCAC’s toolkit example, a $24,000 consolidation loan at 7% and $800 a month, which gives 34 months and $2,459 of interest, matching FCAC. The 13.4% effective rate is the annual rate that sets $15,000 received against 36 payments of $508.13. Card months were also confirmed with the closed-form payoff formula.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

Send it to a friend, a family member or a coworker with the same question. It takes one tap.

How this page was made: Gizly uses AI tools to help research and draft its guides. Krish Paul, the editor, is responsible for what Gizly publishes. Spot an error? Tell us and we will fix it.

Keep reading

Compare before you switch

Rates and offers checked against each bank’s own page.

Krish Paul

Krish Paul owns and edits Gizly, an independent Canadian money site. Each guide cites the government rules and institution terms it relies on, with the date the figures were checked.

Gizly
Logo